Contact me

These days, I'm the director of the American Library Association' s Office for Intellectual Freedom. I'm also executive director and secretary of the Freedom to Read Foundation. See "About Me" for contact information.

Monday, September 7, 2009

District 9 - movie review with spoiler

I knew we were in trouble when all the previews were horror films. But when "District 9" started, the tone was very different, like a documentary. For a while. The premise of the film was on the one hand intriguing: some 2 million plus aliens are stranded in Johannesburg, South Africa. After 20 years, the "camp" where they were rounded up has devolved into a slum. As a result of xenophobia and fear, the aliens, called "prawns" by the natives, are about to be forcibly relocated to a camp farther from town.

On the other hand, let's just stop a minute to think about that. After traversing vast interstellar distances, the command module of the mothership just fell out, leaving the mothership moribund (but hanging effortlessly in the sky over Jotown) and it took 20 years to find and refuel it? As premises go, it's a little lame. But hey, I'm watching a movie about aliens, so suspending disbelief is certainly an option.

It's hard not to cringe at the all-too-accurate portrayal of the worst of human behavior. The film was itself modeled on "district 6" in the days of apartheid, a holding area for blacks which was then declared a "whites only" area. Moreover, "District 9" shows the arrogance of military-backed abrogation of civil rights, medical experimentation, the gleeful slaughter of baby aliens, and the trade of food for weapons.

But "District 9" also features a dual transformation: a psychological change in the petty bureaucrat charged with implementing the relocation, triggered by a physiological change in which he literally starts to identify with the aliens. And we begin to get a different view of the aliens, whose language, technology, and culture are clearly complex.

Unanswered: this species seems to put a lot of attention on weaponry. There's a suggestion that they have a beehive-like social organization: a leader class, and drones. But do we know anything else about their social structures? No. Why did they come in the first place? Unknown. How was their language come to be understood, and by whom? Unknown. How often does the command module fall out of the ship upon docking? Unknown.

But after all the pyrotechnics of exploding bodies, ripped off heads, handheld cameras all jittery in the slums, etc., you find yourself eager for a little peace and quiet.

The end is a classic science fiction twist: you become your enemy. The possibility for love and redemption is made clear. So all in all, a fascinating movie -- but at least two members of my family watched a lot of it with their eyes closed.

8 comments:

notemily said...

yeah, I liked the plot, but there were way too many people exploding and spattering their insides on the camera lens for my comfort.

The Chemist said...

I like fake movie violence. Red corn syrup? Sign me up! It rarely bothers me because it looks fake much of the time. I've seen real violence in news footage, and that I don't have much stomach for.

I too enjoyed the movie, and I took it for what it was. A problem most SF writers have with exposition is in trying to explain things without lecturing the audience.

A sort of "soft" SF story like this is more about human foibles and social issues, so they probably felt it was unnecessary. To a large extent I think adding details would have been superfluous anyway. They had a premise and they went for it pretty single-mindedly, yet it still took a pretty long time. I can't find much fault with them for cutting what would have turned out to be unnecessary exposition out of the film.

Leslie said...

I made the mistake of seeing this film with two people who really wanted to see it, two boys that insisted on giggling like hyperactive five-year-olds every time someone's head exploded. And then even more so with the grav cannon hurling a pig at the one guy. [Admittedly, I laughed a touch at that.]

My issue was more with the vomiting. Bleh.

[By the way, I managed to follow a link to your blog via Neil Gaiman's and started reading things other than what he linked to. You are an extremely thoughtful and interesting read.]

Atul said...

Hi, nice blog. i had watch district 9 movie, it was a nice sci-fri movie.

Steve Davies said...

In point of historical accuracy - all races lived in District 6 - white, black and mixed. This "offence" was one of the motivations that caused the apartheid regime to declare it a slum that needed to be cleared.

Jamie said...

Interesting comment about the nature of the "offence." Can't have tolerance and integration, now, can we? Thank.

bitheads said...

I don’t know If I said it already, but this so good stuff keep up the good work. I read a lot of blogs on a daily basis and for the most part
Twilight New Moon
just wanted to make a quick comment to say I’m glad I found your blog. Thanks.

Best regards
Berita Di Blogosphere Blogosphere News

sAm BabA said...

nice read, i think District 9 was a better movie than avatar. i also download District 9 movie from http://www.pzack.com/