Sunday, June 7, 2015

Are libraries socialist?

In the very conservative Douglas County, Colorado, people sometimes told me, angrily, that the library was "socialist." That's libertarian shorthand for "an unnecessary program that steals my money through taxes." But we won't get very far if we allow those opposed to our aims to define our terms.

First, as I hope to make clear (in the book I'm working on), libraries are not only important, but a staggering return on investment. And taxation is not theft; it is a well-tested mechanism for a people to pay for essential services that don't easily lend themselves to short-term profit (think public roads, sanitation, court systems, etc.).

Second, a more precise definition of socialism is "a way of organizing a society in which major industries are owned and controlled by the government rather than by individual people and companies." Typically, socialism requires both the "production and distribution of goods" to be managed by the government.

By this definition, there are ways in which the label does apply: the assets of the public library are in fact collectively held; they belong not to one person, but to the larger community. Further, the public library (in the United States of America) is typically a unit of government, either municipal, county, or (in the case of "district libraries,") subdivisions of the state. Public libraries are publicly accountable, and "equal access to all" is the point. So the distribution of goods is also shared.

But there is a fundamental way in which the library is not socialist: the production of goods. While some libraries do indeed produce books (a trend that will grow), and it could be argued that the provision of public space and programs is often "produced" by library staff, the overwhelming stock of the library is and will continue to be produced by others: mainly individuals, but also (as in newspapers, magazines, and electronic resources) by corporations. The public sector invests in the private; the private sector (through taxes and philanthropy) invests in the public.

All economies are a mix of capitalism and socialism. So the library is both socialist and non-socialist. And while that truth may trouble some uncompromising libertarians, most people are more concerned with the efficacy and value of an institution than its ideological purity.

9 comments:

nick said...

There's also the idea of communities voluntarily pooling money for a library as well as those libraries that were setup throughout the west via grants by that Rockefeller guy. I think people take issue with the idea that, with taxes, you're forced to pay for something you may never use, despite whatever 'greater good' is said to result.

brindhaajay said...

Interesting post! Thanks for writing it.I always like and such a super contents of these post.
JAVA Training in Chennai
Selenium Training in Chennai
Java classes in chennai
core Java training in chennai
Best Selenium Training Institute in Chennai
selenium Classes in chennai
Java Training in OMR
selenium training in anna nagar

digital marketer said...

I see your blog regularly. Your blog is very useful for us. Neuro Coaching Transicional. La metodología del coaching y las herramientas de PNL enfocadas en los procesos personales, su contexto y la determinación de encontrar el verdadero propósito de la vida, desarrollando a pleno el potencial personal para vivir una vida enfocada al éxito con resultados permanentes y a corto plazo. If you are screaming out “coaching personal en linea” you’ve come to the most elite essay coaching personal en linea....Click here

abhi pranesh said...

Thanks for posting this information it really useful for everyone.
French Classes in Chennai
french courses in chennai
Spoken English Classes in Chennai
TOEFL Coaching in Chennai
pearson vue test center in chennai
German Language Course in Chennai
French Classes in T Nagar
French Classes in Anna Nagar

Anjali Siva said...

I really enjoyed while reading your article and it is good to know the latest updates. Do post more.
Data Science Course in Chennai
Data Analytics Courses in Chennai
Data Analyst Course in Chennai
R Programming Training in Chennai
Data Analytics Training in Chennai
Machine Learning Course in Chennai
Machine Learning Training in Velachery
Data Science Training in Chennai

Kayal m said...

your explanation way is too good, very easy to understand for all readers. Thank you for providing the best details and I want more unique posts.
Primavera Training in Chennai
Primavera Course in Chennai
Tableau Training in Chennai
Spark Training in Chennai
Power BI Training in Chennai
Excel Training in Chennai
Oracle Training in Chennai
Oracle DBA Training in Chennai
Social Media Marketing Courses in Chennai

Vicky Ram said...

Good explanation with appropriate solution.

Guest posting sites
Education

Digitalmarketing said...
This comment has been removed by the author.
Digitalmarketing said...

I have perused your blog its appealing and noteworthy. I like it your blog.
digital marketing company in chennai,
digital marketing agency in india,
digital marketing company in chennai,
online marketing company in chennai,
digital marketing company in india,
digital marketing services,
digital marketing company

jlarue.com - Welcome

In November of 2018, I left my position at ALA in Chicago to return to my Colorado-based writing, speaking, and consulting career. So I'...